Throughout the first series she-cats had kits with unknown fathers.

Well, I did some research on Frostfur's "mysterious mate".

Frostfur's a pure whit she-cat with blue eyes. Her mother was brown with a ginger patch while her father was a black tom.

Frostfur's kits: Brackenfur: Golden-brown tabby; Brightheart: White cat with ginger patches; Thornclaw: Golden-brown tabby; Cinderpelt: Dark gray she-cat.

WHO I HAVE DECIDED IS HER MYSTERIOUS MATE:
Lionheart is a golden tabby. This explains Brackenfur and Thornclaw's goldenish fur, and tabby markings, and quite possibly Brightheart's ginger patches.

But what about Cinderpelt? Like I said earlier, Frostfur's father is black-furred. This could definitely explain Cinderpelt's dark gray fur.

I spent like a whole 2-3 hours researching this and I am quite satisfied with the results.

If you solve any more mysteries please post below!

[[I ship FrostxLion ]]

What about Ravenpaws parents, Spottedleafs parents.?

their parents are already known.

Spottedleaf: Swiftbreeze x Adderfang

Ravenpaw: Robinwing x Fuzzypelt

;)

Bluestar's prophecy reveals Spottedleaf's parents I believe....what I wanna know....how did Leafpool, a brown she-cat with white underbelly and toes and Crofeather, a black tom, neither of them having the gene (from what I could gather, considering green eyes are dominate to Leafpool's eye color and crowfetaher's family doesn't seem to carry green eyes) have a child with green eyes? I want to know!

Ah, but since when does cats from the spirit underworld take physical form and cross dimensions? Sometimes logic isn't always there.

Bluestars sister is Snowfur, Snowfurs son is Whitestorm, Whitestroms daughter is Sorreltail, Sorreltails mate is Brakenfur, Brakenfurs sister was Cinderpelt, Cinderpelts sisiter was Brightheart, and Cloudtail (Firestars kin) mated with Brightheart XD

ok....xD

Cool stuff there Gus!
Say isnt it wierd that scourge is firestars half brother but didnt even know it and it repeats on brambleclaw and hawkfrost being half brothers and in the end both scourge and hawkfrost died to there half thunderclan brother!

Kinda but not really

Ok!
Meow!?

Why 'meow?'